Tips

Meest gebruikte links
Actieve topics
Laatste kaartcommentaar

Spoilers
Innistrad Crimson Vow
Crimson Vow Commander
Innistrad Midnight Hunt
Midnight Hunt Commander
Adventures in the Forgotten Realms (AFR)
Commander Forgotten Realms (AFC)
Modern Horizons 2 (MH2)
Modern Horizons 1 Timeshifts (H1R)
Strixhaven (STX)
Strixhaven Mystical Archive (STA)
Commander 2021 (C21)

Alle spoilers zijn te maken in de catalogus en staan met linkjes op de winkel homepage.

Verkoop of ruil je overtollige kaarten aan Nedermagic via onze dynamische inkooplijst of vraag per email een bod op je gehele collectie.

Surreal Memoir

Serie: Commander 2020 (C20)

Rarity: Uncommon Commander 2020 Uncommon

Komt voor in

Serie Normaal Foil
Commander 2020
 4
0,15    
Iconic Masters
 8
0,20
 -
0,40
Rise of the Eldrazi
 8
0,15
 3
0,40
Surreal Memoir | Commander 2020

 Op voorraad 

€ 0,15 (4x)

 Kopen

Veilig betalen met iDeal

 Reactie plaatsen
29-12-2010 18:32:00

"At random" houdt juist in dat je niet mag kiezen.

29-12-2010 18:31:00

return an instant at random...Dit houdt in dat je gewoon een instant uit je graveyard mag kiezen toch?

15-5-2010 17:04:00

Bedankt en inderdaad Magnus, ik weet wel dat het vanaf de stack naar de graveyard gaat, maar ik wilde vooral duidelijk het verschil tussen "Hand->Stack" en "Exiled->Stack" maken. Hoe dan ook, ik heb een bevestigend antwoord gekregen

Official Judge Mark (337) Offline Profiel Stuur persoonlijk bericht
15-5-2010 16:08:00

Bijna helemaal correct Als hij niet resolved, dan gaat hij van de STACK naar de graveyard. Hij is namelijk niet meer in je hand wanneer hij gecast is. Maar als hij niet resolved (bv. omdat hij gecounterd wordt) dan wordt hij niet exiled, want rebound werkt alleen als de kaart wel resolved.

15-5-2010 14:20:00

Klopt, je zou hem pas exilen bij het resolven, en hij resolved niet meer.

15-5-2010 14:10:00

Even voor de duidelijkheid. Ik begrijp het dus goed dat wanneer deze spel niet resolved deze dus vanuit je hand direct naar de graveyard gaat? Geen rebound dan toch?

Official Judge Mark (337) Offline Profiel Stuur persoonlijk bericht
15-5-2010 12:57:00

Als je een spell cast, waar vandaan dan ook, gaat de spell naar de stack. En een resolvede spell gaat naar de graveyard, behalve als op de kaart specifiek staat dat hij ergens anders naartoe gaat.

Dat is bij Rebound zo, maar ALLEEN als je hem uit hand cast. Dus de spell volgt deze weg:

Hand -> Stack -> Exile -> Stack -> Graveyard

15-5-2010 12:39:00

Inderdaad, wanneer je iets met rebound vanuit je exile zone speelt komt het weer in je graveyard terecht!

15-5-2010 12:34:00

grave als ik t goed heb onthouden.

15-5-2010 12:33:00

Op het moment dat hij voor de 2e keer gecast wordt (vanuit de exile), dan komt hij toch in de graveyard terecht? Of blijft hij in exile?

Oracle

Sorcery 

Return an instant card at random from your graveyard to your hand.
Rebound (If you cast this spell from your hand, exile it as it resolves. At the beginning of your next upkeep, you may cast this card from exile without paying its mana cost.)

Tournooi-info

Legal in: Vintage, Legacy, Modern, Commander

Officiele rulings

6/15/2010
If a spell with rebound that you cast from your hand doesn’t resolve for any reason (due being countered by a spell like Cancel, or because all of its targets are illegal), rebound has no effect. The spell is simply put into your graveyard. You won’t get to cast it again next turn.

6/15/2010
If you cast a spell with rebound from anywhere other than your hand (such as from your graveyard due to Sins of the Past, from your library due to cascade, or from your opponent’s hand due to Sen Triplets), rebound won’t have any effect. If you do cast it from your hand, rebound will work regardless of whether you paid its mana cost (for example, if you cast it from your hand due to Maelstrom Archangel).

6/15/2010
If a replacement effect would cause a spell with rebound that you cast from your hand to be put somewhere else instead of your graveyard (such as Leyline of the Void might), you choose whether to apply the rebound effect or the other effect as the spell resolves.

6/15/2010
Rebound will have no effect on copies of spells because you don’t cast them from your hand.

6/15/2010
If you cast a spell with rebound from your hand and it resolves, it isn’t put into your graveyard. Rather, it’s exiled directly from the stack. Effects that care about cards being put into your graveyard won’t do anything.

6/15/2010
At the beginning of your upkeep, all delayed triggered abilities created by rebound effects trigger. You may handle them in any order. If you want to cast a card this way, you do so as part of the resolution of its delayed triggered ability. Timing restrictions based on the card’s type (if it’s a sorcery) are ignored. Other restrictions are not (such as the one from Rule of Law).

6/15/2010
If you are unable to cast a card from exile this way, or you choose not to, nothing happens when the delayed triggered ability resolves. The card remains exiled for the rest of the game, and you won’t get another chance to cast the card. The same is true if the ability is countered (due to Stifle, perhaps).

6/15/2010
If you cast a card from exile this way, it will go to your graveyard when it resolves, fails to resolve, or is countered. It won’t go back to exile.

6/15/2010
Surreal Memoir isn’t targeted. You don’t choose an instant card at random from your graveyard until it resolves. Once you randomly select a card, it’s too late for players to respond.

6/15/2010
If you have only one instant card in your graveyard as Surreal Memoir resolves, that’s the one you’ll return to your hand.

6/15/2010
If you’re playing a format involving only cards from the _Urza’s Saga_(TM) set and later, you may change the order of your graveyard at any time. That means the easiest way to choose an instant card at random from your graveyard is to take all the instant cards in your graveyard, turn them face down, shuffle them, and pick a card. Then you just put the rest back.

6/15/2010
If you’re playing a format involving cards printed earlier than the _Urza’s Saga_ set, you may not reorder your graveyard. In this case, you need to be more careful when selecting an instant card at random, perhaps by using dice, writing the names of the instant cards on slips of paper and choosing one of them randomly, or carefully noting the existing graveyard order so you can reestablish it after performing the method suggested above, for example.

6/15/2010
If you have multiple instant cards in your graveyard with the same name, and one of them is being targeted by another spell on the stack or is enchanted (with Spellweaver Volute, for example), you must differentiate them so you know which one (if any) is chosen at random. In that case, it may be better to use dice or another method that allows you to differentiate between the instant cards to choose one at random.

6/15/2010
All players get to see which card you chose at random.

Decktips